
- Key Highlights
- What Each Roof Style Actually Is
- Regular Roof: Cheapest, and Sometimes Exactly Right
- A-Frame Vertical: The One We Recommend Most
- Gambrel: Buying Headroom Without Buying Taller Legs
- Gambrel vs A-Frame vs Regular Roof, Side by Side
- How Roof Style Connects to Height, Doors, and What Fits Inside
- What Your County Enforces, and Why It May Pick the Roof for You
- Site Prep, Install, and What Roof Style Costs You
- Picking the Roof for Your Barn
Every barn buyer hits the same fork in the road. You have the width, the length, and the leg height figured out, and then the configurator asks what roof style you want. Suddenly there is a price difference of a few thousand dollars between three options that look almost the same in a thumbnail. The gambrel vs A-frame roof question comes up on our phones daily, usually with regular roof thrown in as the cheap third option. The silhouette is the least important part of that decision. What actually separates these three is how water leaves the building, how much usable space sits above your head, and whether your county will permit it.
Key Highlights
- Regular roof has rounded corners and horizontal panels. It costs the least and sheds the least. Good for mild climates and open ag structures, poor for snow country.
- A-frame vertical is the workhorse. Panels run peak to eave, so water and snow slide off instead of crossing seams.
- Gambrel has two pitch breaks per side. It buys real headroom inside the upper volume without paying for taller legs.
- Panel direction matters more than roof shape for how long the building lasts.
- Your snow load can eliminate regular roof from the conversation before you ever pick a color.
- All three carry the same 14-gauge frame and 29-gauge panels as standard, with upgrades available.
- Tell us your county and what is going inside, and we will spec the roof around it. Call (208) 572-1441.
What Each Roof Style Actually Is
All three are built on the same tubular steel frame. The difference is the shape of the truss and the direction the panels run.
Regular roofs feature a rounded eave, like a classic carport. Panels run horizontally along the length of the building, lapped end to end. There is no ridge cap or hat channel underneath. It is the simplest roof we build and the fastest to install.
A-frames square off the eave into a boxed corner and gives you the peaked barn profile most people picture. It comes two ways. A-frame horizontal keeps the panels running lengthwise. A-frame vertical runs them from the peak down to the eave over hat channel, with a ridge cap on top. That second one is what we mean when we say vertical roof.
Gambrel Roofs are the two-slope barn roof. Each side has a steep lower pitch and a shallow upper pitch, with a break where they meet. Every gambrel we build is a vertical roof, because the geometry does not work any other way.
If you want the mechanics of horizontal versus vertical panel systems in more depth across all building types, our metal building roof styles guide covers that side of it. This one stays focused on barns.
Want to compare these roof styles on actual barn configurations? Browse our metal barns, or use the 3D Building Designer to configure your own.
Regular roof: cheapest, and sometimes exactly right
Regular roofs are the budget option, and we sell plenty of them. On a hay cover in Texas, an open equipment shelter in Oklahoma, or a loafing shed keeping sun and rain off livestock, it does the job for less money than anything else on the list.
However, regular roofs are not meant for all environments. Every seam sits crossways to the way water wants to travel, so rain has to get over each lap on the way down. In dry climates that is a non-issue for decades. In wet country, and anywhere snow sits for weeks instead of sliding off, those laps are where problems start.
The rounded eave adds a second effect people do not expect. Snow does not release off a curved edge the way it does off a boxed one. It builds up, freezes at the perimeter, and sits there adding load.
The honest rule we give buyers over the phone: if your county publishes a real ground snow load, cross regular roof off the list. In mild country, with an open or semi-open ag building, it is a good use of your money. Regular-roof options run through our utility buildings and metal carports lines as well as our barns, including builds like the 42x26x12 regular roof barn.
A-frame vertical: the one we recommend most
If you told us nothing about your property except that you want a barn that lasts, we would put you on an A-frame vertical roof. It handles the widest range of conditions with the fewest compromises.
Why panel direction changes the life of the building
On a vertical roof, each panel runs in one continuous piece from ridge to eave. Water travels down a rib with nothing in its way, and snow does the same. It slides rather than sits, so the structure carries live load for hours instead of weeks.
Underneath, hat channel gives the panels a support grid and the ridge cap seals the peak. That system is what lets a vertical roof carry heavier snow ratings, and it is why almost every barn we ship into Idaho, Montana, and Colorado leaves the shop as a vertical roof.
Where A-frame gives up ground to gambrel
A-frame has one pitch on each side, so the volume above your eave narrows steadily as it climbs. You get a tall center and very little usable space either side of it. For a barn storing equipment on the floor, fine. For a barn where hay, feed, or a mezzanine was going up top, it wastes the room.
Our barn inventory leans heavily A-frame vertical for that reason. Browse the range on our metal barns page, or the horse barns line if you have stalls in the plan.
Comparing A-frame and gambrel on a similar footprint? See our 30x30x12 A-Frame Barn and 30x30x12 Gambrel Barn, then customize your layout in the 3D Building Designer.
Gambrel: buying headroom without buying taller legs
A gambrel roof solves a problem the other two cannot. It gives you a usable second volume overhead while your leg height stays the same. The steep lower pitch pushes the roof outward before it turns, so the space above your eave stays wide instead of pinching toward the ridge.
On a 30-foot-wide gambrel, that upper volume is walkable in the middle. It’s the reason American barns were built this way for 150 years before anybody made them out of steel.
When the gambrel is worth the extra cost
Order a gambrel when the space above the main floor has a job. Hay is the classic one. Feed, tack, seasonal equipment, and overhead racking are the modern ones. Buyers finishing a barn into living space lean this way too, since the profile handles a loft bedroom or a vaulted ceiling better than a single pitch.
Skip it when that volume is dead space. If you are parking tractors and closing the door, you are paying for bends, trim, and labor that will never carry anything. Going from 10-foot legs to 12-foot legs is the cheaper way to get clearance if height at the door is all you need.
Our gambrels come fully enclosed and vertical as standard, in sizes from the 18x20x8 gambrel barn up through the 48x45x12 gambrel barn.
"Not sure whether the loft space justifies a gambrel? Call (208) 572-1441 and tell us what you plan to put up there. We will price it both ways so you can see the difference before you decide."
Gambrel vs A-frame vs regular roof, side by side
| Factor | Regular roof | A-frame vertical | Gambrel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Panel direction | Horizontal, lapped | Peak to eave, continuous | Peak to eave, continuous |
| Eave shape | Rounded | Boxed | Boxed with pitch break |
| Snow performance | Weakest, snow tends to sit | Strongest, sheds fast | Strong, steep lower slope sheds well |
| Usable overhead space | Minimal | Narrow, center only | Widest of the three |
| Relative cost | Lowest | Middle | Highest |
| Certification for high loads | Limited | Available | Available |
| Best suited to | Open ag cover, mild climates | Enclosed barns, shops, snow country | Hay lofts, overhead storage, barn homes |
How Roof Style Connects To Height, Doors, and What Fits Inside
Roof style does not change the size of your doors. Leg height does. A roll-up on the sidewall needs roughly 2 feet of leg above the top of the opening no matter which roof sits above it, so a 12-foot door still means 14-foot legs on a gambrel exactly as it would on an A-frame.
What roof style does change is the volume above that line. On an A-frame, peak height gives clearance in a narrow strip down the center, useful for a raised implement or a tall antenna. On a gambrel, that clearance spreads across most of the width, which is what makes a loft floor practical.
So the order goes: find the tallest thing that has to drive through the door, set leg height from that, then choose the roof based on what happens above it. Buyers who do it backward end up with a beautiful gambrel and a door their equipment will not clear. Our guide to sidewall, peak, and clear height walks through the measurements, and the door placement guide covers where the openings should land.
One more thing to settle early. If a lean-to is in the plan, tell us at quote time. On an A-frame the lean-to ties in cleanly at the eave. On a gambrel the lower slope is steep, so the tie-in point and the lean-to roof pitch both have to be worked out in the drawings rather than added on later.
What Your County Enforces, and Why it May Pick the Roof For You
Snow load and wind speed are set by your county, and they can rule out a roof style regardless of what you would prefer.
Get your county's numbers before you fall in love with a configuration. We pull them for your exact address while quoting, and the frame gets built to match. Our snow and wind load page shows how the ratings work, and the certified permits explainer covers what your building department will want to see. If you are budgeting, our breakdown of how codes and snow loads move the price is the honest version.
Building for local weather requirements? Review our Snow and Wind Loads guide, then call (208) 572-1441 with your building location and intended use.
Site prep, install, and what roof style costs you
Site prep is the same across all three. The pad has to be level, and the crew needs clear working room around the perimeter to square the frame and fasten panels from outside. Roof style does not change either requirement. Details are on our site preparation page.
Install time does change. Regular roof goes up fastest. Vertical takes longer because hat channel goes on before the panels. Gambrel takes longest, with more bends, more trim, and more cuts. None of that changes what you pay, since delivery and installation are included, but it is worth knowing when you plan your week.
On price, the gap between the three is real but smaller than most buyers assume, and it is dwarfed by leg height, door count, and your snow rating. Panel and tubing upgrades sit on top of whichever roof you pick. Standard is 14-gauge tubing with 29-gauge panels, and both can be upgraded. Our comparisons of 12-gauge versus 14-gauge framing and 26-gauge versus 29-gauge panels cover when those upgrades earn their cost. Financing and rent-to-own are on the financing page.
Picking The Roof for Your Barn
Start with your county's snow load, because it can settle the question for you. If the number is real, you are choosing between A-frame vertical and gambrel. From there it comes down to one question: does the space above your head have a job? If yes, gambrel. If no, A-frame vertical and put the savings into leg height or a lean-to.
Design your barn in 3D at EngineeredMetalBuildings.com, or call (208) 572-1441 and tell us your county and what is going inside. We will pull your loads, spec the roof around them, and quote the shell delivered and installed.
Ready to compare your options? Design Your Building Online, browse our metal barn models, or call (208) 572-1441 for a free quote.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes. Regular, A-frame, and gambrel barns are all framed with 14-gauge tubing and covered with 29-gauge panels as standard, with 12-gauge tubing and 26-gauge panel upgrades available on any of them.
Yes, but the tie-in has to be designed into the order rather than added later. The lower slope on a gambrel is steep, so the attachment point and the lean-to pitch both get worked out in the drawings. Tell us at quote time and we will lay it out with the main structure.
No. Door size is governed by leg height, not roof shape. A roll-up door on the sidewall needs about 2 feet of leg height above the opening regardless of whether the roof above it is regular, A-frame, or gambrel.
Yes, in mild climates where snow load is minimal and the building will not be certified for heavy loads.
It’s worth it when the space above your main floor has a real job, like hay storage, feed, overhead racking, or a loft in a barn you plan to finish. It might not be worth it when that space stays empty.
A vertical roof, either A-frame or gambrel. Panels run continuously from the peak to the eave, so snow slides off instead of collecting on horizontal seams, and the boxed eave releases it cleanly.
An A-frame has one pitch on each side running straight from the peak to the eave. A gambrel has two pitches per side with a break between them, steeper on the bottom and shallower on top.










